Thursday, February 13, 2014

False Memories

The opinion of other people can alter our personal memories without our realizing it, according to research by neuroscientists. Writing in the journal Science, Washington University scientists tell about an experiment related to memory conformity. Using an eyewitness style documentary, they found false feedback from others affected the responses of 7 out of 10 people to questions about what they remembered from the film. Even more remarkable is the fact that 4 out of 7 people were not simply conforming to the group, but actually reporting what they now believed to be true.

A team of psychologists showed the quick deterioration of memories by interviewing people about how they first learned about the 9/11 attacks just a few days after the attacks took place. When the researchers came back after one year, more than a third of the details recalled by study participants had changed. In three years time, nearly half of the details were different.

Jonah Lehrer offers this conclusion about these experiments in Wired Magazine:
This research helps explain why a shared narrative can often lead to totally unreliable individual memories. We are so eager to conform to the collective, to fit our little lives into the arc of history, that we end up misleading ourselves.

Humans are storytelling machines. We don’t passively perceive the world – we tell stories about it, translating the helter-skelter of events into tidy narratives. This is often a helpful habit, helping us make sense of mistakes, consider counterfactuals and extract a sense of meaning from the randomness of life. But our love of stories comes with a serious side-effect: like all good narrators, we tend to forsake the facts when they interfere with the plot. We’re so addicted to the anecdote that we let the truth slip away until, eventually, those stories we tell again and again become exercises in pure fiction.